KDP Select – Thanks, but no thanks.
So the whole self-publishing community is shaken up today about Amazon’s newest announcement, KDP Select. A lot of authors are jumping right on it…basically it’s the option to make your book available to Amazon Prime members for free in their own lending library (this is separate, as far as I know, from the normal “lend this to a friend” feature).
There’s a really huge catch though – and that is that Amazon requires exclusive rights for the time your book is in the program, and the non-compete clause that goes with that. Frankly, I’m surprised so many authors are rushing to sign up – because at the moment (not for much longer, apparently), indie authors *have the power* to nip that power grab in the bud.
I’m also really surprised at how many authors seem to think Amazon does anything specifically to “help” or “be nice to” indie authors. I am 100% positive that Amazon does what it does to make money…nothing else. They don’t want to offer this as a service to indies, they simply need more books in their prime lending library (since traditional publishers aren’t going along as quietly as Amazon would like), and they know that indie authors will do nearly anything for a bit of exposure. So they dangle the three things authors want most – a little cash, a little exposure, and the ability to make your book free for 5 days – knowing that a lot of them aren’t confident enough in their business acumen to fight them on the exclusivity and non-compete terms.
Amazon isn’t out to help indies here. They listened to what indies want (access to the prime lending library, and the ability to make books free), and twisted it to use for their own gain. They aren’t for or against indie authors – they’re for making as much profit as possible, and they’re not above leveraging indies for that purpose.
I am *not* against Amazon…or any other retailer. I spend plenty of money there, and I’m a prime member myself. And I’m not even surprised or angry that they would do this – it’s business, and for them, it’s *good* business…they don’t have to give a lot to make their prime library explode.
I *am* surprised that so many indie authors, who have the power right now to take control and *insist* on better contract terms (because they have the most important thing Amazon needs for the Prime library to succeed – content), are so willing to play along with Amazon and not use the power they have to ensure better contract terms right from the start. If indies refused, by and large, to enroll in this program until the exclusivity and non-compete clauses were stricken, Amazon would have no choice but to either run with a much smaller library of books for Prime borrowers, or to back down on the terms.
Yes, I really think indies have that much power right now. Or they did, until literally thousands of them just jumped right on board and allowed Amazon to dictate the contract.
It’s disappointing, because I think we’ve missed a major opportunity to hang on to leverage of our own. But that’s the thing about being independent…we all get to make our own choices. Unfortunately, I think signing up for this program is a choice that will show Amazon (and other companies) just how much power we’re willing to give away as a whole…and that very well could be a bad thing in the future. Much like authors who blindly signed/sign away too many rights to traditional publishers.
In any case, you won’t see any of my titles or any BSB titles in the Prime lending library. They’re still available to lend to friends after you buy them, and they’ll still be available on Amazon and the other major retail sites, as well as the BSB store, of course. It may cost me in the end, but I wouldn’t sign an exclusivity or non-compete clause with a traditional publisher (or at least if exclusive rights, there would be a lot more money in it for me, but no non-compete clause, for sure), so there’s no way I’d agree to one with Amazon (or any other retailer who wants to try that).
**Your first comment here will be moderated. After you've been approved, comments will post a few minutes after you submit them. Thanks for your time!



Jamie, you go girl. I am proud of you for not being a lemming and for thinking things out. You are very logical and sensible. You have great business savvy. Thanks for sharing this great blog post.
Ardee-ann
Reply to this
I have nothing against free books. I like them very much as a reader. However, at the rate indie authors keep offering free books, it devalues them. We are just about getting to the stage where indie authors are not all considered people-not-good-enough-to-go-through-traditional-publishing. That stigma I think is lifted for the most part. But when people do keep offering their books for free, that makes a reader wonder, why? I know a guy who often downloads free Indie books from Amazon, and then when he finishes them, for the most part his response is: "Well it was all right. But you can't expect much from a free book."
Reply to this
Thanks, Ardee-ann.
Dolly, I agree. And the problem is that the authors chasing the ability to give their work away are really just chasing sales rank and bestseller lists, when neither of those *really* matters when it comes to just making a profit writing. I suppose if you're after a trad. pub deal, then that would be important, but since that's not what I want, I'm just as happy to sell a few books each month at a higher price (plus some at a lower price for less words) and keep building a bigger backlist. The readers who are willing to pay a bit more are often people who will actually *read* the book...much of the time, free books just languish after they're downloaded - you're absolutely right in that readers put more stock in something they paid even a little more for.
I do give away free stories - but just the drafts via my serials. I feel like a story I took the time to clean up and polish and get a nice cover for should cost *something*, at least.
Too many writers are just desperate to have those high rankings, I think.
Reply to this
YES! HELL, YES! That is all.
Reply to this